Analysis

Formula 1 Canadian GP

Analysis: Is F1 set for another flexi-wing war?

With the fight at the front of the Formula 1 grid closing up, the quest for aerodynamic advantage has once again opened up talk about what teams may or may not be doing with flexi wings.

Matt Somerfield

Matt Somerfield

Published: Jun 16, 2016, 7:40 AM

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing RB12 leads Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF16-H

The latest saga emerged after the Spanish Grand Prix, when a rear facing camera from Sebastian Vettel's Ferrari showed his rear wing and monkey seat were rotating back at high speed.

There were further suggestions that Red Bull's front wing was acting in a similar way - to reduce drag on the straights while producing maximum downforce at low speed.

With this weekend's race in Baku taking place at a track where teams wants maximum downforce and minimum drag, it is likely there will once again be close scrutiny on what all teams are up to.

And that will be especially true after the FIA in Canada executed tougher checks - 50 percent over the prescribed limits - to see if anything untoward was happening. All cars were given the all-clear.

Rigid parts

 

Jo Bauer, FIA Delegate

Jo Bauer, FIA Delegate

Photo by: XPB Images

 

Flexibility in bodywork, especially loaded elements, is inevitable and parts cannot be made infinitely rigid, otherwise they would buckle under load.

However, parts must pass load and deflection tests conducted by the scrutineers in order that they don't become a moveable aerodynamic device (Article 15.3 of the technical regulations).

These tests have been in place for several years - although the forces used have increased as teams have pushed the limits with what they are doing.

 

Flexible rear wing

Flexible rear wing

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

 

Flexible front wings became a intense development battleground in 2010 as the teams looked to regain lost performance in the regulation switch only a year earlier.

Those initial 'flexi-wing' concepts were designed to bow at their outer extremities to affect how the wing operated and improve how the airflow moved around the car.

The load tests were subsequently increased by the FIA in order to scupper their implementation, but, as always, the designers found new ways to deal with the issues.

Aero-elasticity was pushed in different directions, with some found to be rotating the entire wing structure to change the wing's angle of attack.

Red Bull got a ticking off at the end of 2014 when it was found that its front wing flaps were actually hinged, allowing the wing to deflect under load. This directly reduced drag and changed the shape of the airflow dispatched downstream.

This led to the introduction of a push test, where the FIA applies a load to the trailing edge of the flap to determine if its movement is above an acceptable threshold.

That is why you will now find a spar inbetween the upper and penultimate flaps on most front wings to limit the movement of the flap during this test.

Prior to this, almost the entire field had realized they could change the shape of the Y250 vortex dependent on the speed of the car.

The latest 'flexible' wing claims

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing

Photo by: Red Bull Content Pool

The current accusation centres around Red Bull having designed its wing in such a way that the flapped section is entirely independent of the footplate and endplate.

This could allow it to flex at speed, circumnavigating the push and load tests independently, although its car has passed all checks.

Meanwhile, rearward facing footage of the Ferrari during the Spanish GP seemed to show the entire rear wing structure, mounting pylon and monkey seat all tilt back under load on the main straight, which is thought to significantly improve straight line speed.

Again, it's not the first time we have seen this phenomenon, with the most recent example being Williams in 2014. Footage of the FW36 seemed to produce something similar to what we saw with the Ferrari.

 

Valtteri Bottas, Williams FW36

Valtteri Bottas, Williams FW36

Photo by: XPB Images

 

However, it remains unclear as to whether this was (or is) an intentional design consideration or an ill-conceived side effect of the team's rear-wing design, which didn't feature a centre-mounted support pylon like the rest of the field.

Unsurprisingly, the FW36 regularly topped the speed traps in 2014, but the drivers bemoaned a lack of aerodynamic consistency. Could this have been a side-effect of the re-attachment of airflow as the wing tilted back to its upright position during cornering?

For there will be an arbitrary period of time that passes where the wing will not provide the necessary downforce as speed bleeds off under normal operating conditions and a tilted wing comes back into position.

This is due to airflow detachment, a phase whereby the airflow leaves the aerodynamic surface, which results in a loss of downforce and instability.

It's unsurprising then that we saw the Ferrari drivers fighting their machines in Spain with what could have been an unstable downforce level in transient conditions.

Where to now?

Whether or not Red Bull and Ferrari are going beyond the 'spirit' of the rules is a matter of debate. But, for now, the FIA is satisfied that neither team is doing anything against the regulations.

That stance will now leave the two teams' rivals with a clear choice: keep lobbying the FIA to make sure that there is nothing nefarious going on, or pursue similar 'flexi' design concepts themselves.

It will be fascinating to see where F1's aerodynamic battleground goes from here.

 

Rear wing stress test

Rear wing stress test

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Read also :

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Previous article Verstappen exit good for Toro Rosso, says Sainz

Next article New F1 tyre pressure checks still some way off

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

More from

Matt Somerfield



Gallery: How F1 tech evolved during the 2024 season

Formula 1

Formula 1

Gallery: How F1 tech evolved during the 2024 season



How McLaren’s rear wing push changed the game in F1

Formula 1

Formula 1

How McLaren’s rear wing push changed the game in F1



How 2026 F1 rules will help avoid identikit designs

Formula 1

Formula 1

How 2026 F1 rules will help avoid identikit designs

Latest news



Corey Heim will drive No. 67 in 2027 NASCAR Cup season

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup 45 min

Corey Heim will drive No. 67 in 2027 NASCAR Cup season



Toyota defends approach over GR GT3 after Stephane Ratel voiced concerns 

WEC

WEC WEC 55 min

Toyota defends approach over GR GT3 after Stephane Ratel voiced concerns 



Honda explains why MotoGP's 850cc bikes aren't far off 1000cc pace

MotoGP

MGP MotoGP

Portuguese GP

2 h

Honda explains why MotoGP's 850cc bikes aren't far off 1000cc pace



39th Annual Autosport Awards to celebrate global motorsport achievements; Mario Andretti to be honoured with Gold Medal

Autosport Awards

AAs Autosport Awards 3 h

39th Annual Autosport Awards to celebrate global motorsport achievements; Mario Andretti to be honoured with Gold Medal

Feature

Discover prime content



The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point



What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Stuart Codling

What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?



With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two

Formula 1

By Maurice Hamilton

With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two



How seizing every chance – and making it happen – keeps Pierre Gasly’s fire burning

Formula 1

By Jake Boxall-Legge

How seizing every chance – and making it happen – keeps Pierre Gasly’s fire burning

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts

Subscribe