Analysis
Formula 1
Analysis: The real story behind Mercedes' gearbox dramas
Suffering one reliability problem in Formula 1 can sometimes be down to bad luck, but when a team suffers two on the same component almost simultaneously, that is often a sign that something major has gone wrong.
Jonathan Noble Edd Straw
Edited: Jul 20, 2017, 11:35 AM
Copy link
Share on Viber



















So when Mercedes announced ahead of qualifying for the British Grand Prix that Valtteri Bottas needed a gearbox change – just one week after Lewis Hamilton had to do the same in Austria – alarm bells began to ring.
For while there had been suspicions after Baku (denied by Mercedes) that Hamilton’s failure could have been caused by the bash he got from Sebastian Vettel, it was clear when Bottas’ system needed changing too that this was something far more critical.
And inevitably it prompted questions about whether there was some serious fault with the Mercedes design that left the door open for even more penalties down the line – especially because gearboxes have to last six full weekends.
Mercedes’ demeanour was not one of panic, though. Indeed, while on the outside the situation could have seemed dramatic, the team itself knew it was one that could be easily rectified.
Too aggressive
In simple terms, Mercedes had been too aggressive with the timing of its seamless shift system – and that had damaged the gearbox internals.
Mercedes technical director James Allison said that the team’s bid to extract every element of performance out of the car had resulted in it pushing too hard to shave milliseconds off its shift times.
“In the old days, you’d be in a gear, then you’d be out of a gear and then you’d be in another gear and you’d just lose drive all the time that the gears were in transit from one to the other,” he explained.
“In a seamless shift you are in one gear and then the next one takes over instantly - so there isn’t a loss of drive.
“However, if you imagine the gearbox, when you are shifting up, it’s spinning at a high speed in a lower gear, then you want to upshift the box, all that rotating inertia has to slow down to meet the next gear.
"So seamless though it is, there is still an amount of spinning stuff that needs to be slowed down to meet the next gear.
"Now you can do that gently or you can just let the whole thing go ‘hhhuuurrrgggghhhh’ and sort of wind up and then spin that wind back into the wheels.
“The gentle [way] is done by cutting the torque from the engine, to soften the wind that would occur. The harsh is just letting rip. I can say this because it’s not a sort of thing that no-one else has thought of, it’s a standard thing in F1. It’s just a question of how bold you are with it.”
G-force reality
Mercedes, in the end, simply went too bold. And while it has a thorough reliability sign-off when it comes to development, Allison says the team was caught out by the real world throwing up things – like G-forces – that cannot be simulated on dynos.
“We have a process for signing off any new strategy or any new design and that process is actually quite cautious from an engineering point of view,” he said.
“We try to put it on the track as much as we can, but the opportunities for track running in a risk-free way are limited. So we have dynamometers back in the factory where we can create a fairly good representation of reality.
“We did all of our normal process to prove off a layer of greater aggression with the shift settings than we had used previously. But, despite the fact that everything looked fine in our sign-off process, sadly that particular plan didn’t survive contact with the enemy on the track - where things were a little different, where the g-loads moved the oil around the box differently than you can simulate in a dynamometer.
“So we just overstepped the mark by the tiniest of margins and paid a price."
Ferrari pressure
What the gearbox situation shows is that Mercedes is having to push the limits of its cars perhaps harder than it has done in recent years.
For after three years of dominance in F1, Mercedes is entering new territory this year – where the fight is not just between its two drivers but against Ferrari. And with tenths of a second separating success from defeat, any area where performance can be found needs to be pursued.
Mercedes boss Toto Wolff explains about the efforts that fuel and lubricants supplier Petronas has done: “For me, it is amazing that there are fluids you can extract performance from that I didn’t even know were in the car
“And it adds up. You can find five milliseconds on a cooling product, you can find 15 milliseconds on a hydraulic oil. With the formula of oils and fuels and the density, you can extract so much more performance out of all these crucial parts of the internal combustion engine.
“The gearbox is another good example. Running the right oil in the gearbox can give you a performance advantage, it can give you a weight advantage, it can allow you to race more aggressively in terms of gearshifts. And sometimes as a team you get over-confident.
“That has happened to us on the gearbox. We’ve probably run it too hard and when we stuck the nose in after Baku, we realised.”
Wolff, though, is ultimately proud that Mercedes has maintained strong form throughout a regulation change. He knows that the team has now paid a price for pushing too hard, but reining the aggression in a bit solves its problem on this front.
“Our objective was to come out on top after a year of regulatory change,” he said. “As far as I know, there has been no team in the past that was dominant over a couple of years and has stayed on top through a regulatory change. And this was our objective, to achieve that.
“So you can say it’s not us alone any more. It is probably better for the sport and for the entertainment factor that Ferrari is part of the mix now, but we are pushing so hard.
"And by pushing and trying to keep the development curve steep, you get setbacks. Headrests that become undone, gearboxes that break because you try to extract the last bit of bits that normally have no performance relevance any more, or not a lot. But they do.”
For teams, just like for the drivers themselves out on track, sometimes the price of finding the limits is that you have to pay the consequences for overstepping the mark.
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?
Take our 5 minute survey.
- The Motorsport.com Team
Read and post comments
Read also :
Share Or Save This Story
Copy link
Share on Viber
Previous article Massa column: Qualifying frustrations prove costly in Britain
Next article Force India begins Perez contract renewal talks
Top Comments
There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?
View More & Comment

More from
Jonathan Noble

Brundle awarded OBE in King’s New Year’s honours
Formula 1
Formula 1
Brundle awarded OBE in King’s New Year’s honours

The new rules dilemma that will define the 2025 F1 season
Formula 1
Formula 1
The new rules dilemma that will define the 2025 F1 season

Verstappen issues Red Bull title warning in push for RB21 progress
Formula 1
Formula 1
Australian GP
Verstappen issues Red Bull title warning in push for RB21 progress

More from
Valtteri Bottas

What the Valtteri Bottas contract renewal says about Cadillac's F1 future
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
12 h
What the Valtteri Bottas contract renewal says about Cadillac's F1 future

Valtteri Bottas beats Colton Herta to 2027 Cadillac F1 seat
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
12 h
Valtteri Bottas beats Colton Herta to 2027 Cadillac F1 seat

More from
Mercedes

Kimi Antonelli: Yo-yo racing to return at F1 Las Vegas GP
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 h
Kimi Antonelli: Yo-yo racing to return at F1 Las Vegas GP

The Kimi Antonelli you don't know, told by those closest to him
Formula 1
Formula 1
Mexican GP
22 h
The Kimi Antonelli you don't know, told by those closest to him
Latest news

Honda reveals key F1 power unit change for 2027
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
3 min
Honda reveals key F1 power unit change for 2027

Max Verstappen on F1's WHOOP plan: "It's nobody's business, I don't even know my heart rate"
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 h
Max Verstappen on F1's WHOOP plan: "It's nobody's business, I don't even know my heart rate"

Kimi Antonelli: Yo-yo racing to return at F1 Las Vegas GP
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 h
Kimi Antonelli: Yo-yo racing to return at F1 Las Vegas GP

Max Verstappen: "If they let me write the rules, F1 wouldn’t be allowed in certain places"
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
2 h
Max Verstappen: "If they let me write the rules, F1 wouldn’t be allowed in certain places"
Feature
Discover prime content

Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Formula 1
By Kevin Turner
Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
You have 2 options:
- Become a subscriber.
- Disable your adblocker.
Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here
Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page
Manage Alerts
Subscribe




