Analysis: Why the FIFA corruption scandal could be an opportunity for F1

The ongoing FIFA scandal is offering motorsports' ruling body a golden chance to make Formula 1 lead by example, Kate Walker says

Analysis: Why the FIFA corruption scandal could be an opportunity for F1
FIA logo
Jean Todt, FIA President
FIA Road Safety photoshoot: FIA President Jean Todt, France President François Hollande and ACO President Pierre Fillon
Jean Todt, president of the FIA
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 W06 leads at the start of the race
Sergio Marchionne, Ferrari President and CEO of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles on the grid
FIA logo
Sergio Perez, Sahara Force India F1 VJM08
Graeme Lowdon, Manor F1 Team Chief Executive Officer with Jean Todt, FIA President on the grid
Jean Todt, FIA President
The FIA logo
Romain Grosjean, Lotus F1 E23 makes an unplanned pit stop
Romain Grosjean, Lotus F1 Team
FiA Logo
Carlos Sainz Jr., Scuderia Toro Rosso and Felipe Massa, Williams F1 Team
Rain on the FIA logo

Corruption in sport is a topic that has been the subject of much attention since last-month's arrests of FIFA officials following an investigation into allegations of bribery.

It has also raised some eyebrows in the Formula 1 paddock as it is clear that all sport's governing bodies are now going to be under the spotlight.

The subject of corruption has indeed been gaining momentum for a while now and, at the end of last year, non-governmental organisation Transparency International announced that it would be publishing a series of articles devoted to transparency, governance, and corruption in sport.

This was prompted following FIFA's awarding of World Cups to Qatar and Russia, and IOC president Thomas Bach's revolutionary reform agenda.

Transparency International was involved in the IOC working group on governance in sports organisations, and are broadly supportive of Bach's reform agenda, but others involved in sports governance have been less supportive.

At the 2015 SportAccord convention that body's president, Martin Vizer, used his opening speech to deliver some pretty outspoken remarks.

One observer said: "Vizer essentially accused the IOC of lacking transparency, ignoring the federations, blocking his plans for new multi-sport competitions and wasting money on an Olympic TV channel and opening and closing ceremonies. He described the IOC system as 'expired, outdated, wrong, unfair and not at all transparent.'"

Governments have been joining in on the call to clean up corruption too. British prime minister David Cameron used last week's G7 summit in Germany to say that the FIFA bribery scandal should be the impetus for a concentrated effort to seek out instances of corruption in business, government, and organisations around the globe.

Todt downplays links

Over the weekend FIA president Jean Todt dismissed the possibility that FIFA's corruption scandal would be repeated in motorsport.

He told reporters at the Moscow Formula ePrix that: "There is no way that the FIA could have the same problems with corruption that Fifa are experiencing."

Yet as an organisation, the FIA has areas for development, and would benefit from taking the bull by the horns and seeking to be the international sporting body setting the standards for transparency and governance.

While the FIA received the maximum possible score in just under a fifth of the 63 categories assessed by I Trust Sport during the 2013 presidential elections (the study was commissioned by candidate David Ward), there was also room for improvement.

More transparency

The report recommended increased financial transparency: the publication of salaries and the publication of accounts in line with recognised international standards.

For the FIA to take the initiative and start publishing this information now would demonstrate a federation keen to close the door on potential accusations of corrupt practices within its own body, present and future.

In a time where sports governance is headline news, there is much to be gained from demonstrating a willingness to improve one's own existing standards - or even set new ones for the world to follow.

In some ways, it already does - the I Trust Sport report pointed to the FIA's International Tribunal and International Court of Appeal as being "more comprehensive for dealing with disciplinary matters than comparable systems in most other sports."

The FIA's "extensive investment in non-profit objectives regarding motorsport training and road safety" was also picked out as an example to follow.

The Federation makes much of its membership of full recognition status with the IOC, but the FIFA scandal is the perfect opportunity for organisations with foresight to become standard-bearers in good governance.

The IOC's current reforms include changes to the bidding process, but focus on improving governance and transparency:

Uniquely placed among those organisations with full IOC recognition, the FIA represents everyone, from the motorist, to the pedestrian, to the sports fan.

As a non-profit body investing in safety research, and actively campaigning for improved safety standards for all road users, the FIA has practical and political influence far beyond the realm of sport.

The global reach of its member clubs makes the Federation truly international, and gives it the capacity to lead by example if it is bold enough to set - and spread - new standards of transparency and good governance.

A golden opportunity

Politically, it would be advantageous for the FIA to position itself as one of the most influential bodies in global sport.

First, however, the federation should ensure that its own standards are unimpeachable, particularly with regard to the lack of financial reporting and use of international accounting standards mentioned above.

The assessment and improvement of the FIA's existing practices is an opportunity to become a shining example of transparency and governance in sport.

By working with the IOC in the period of reform, the federation can strengthen its relationships with some of the biggest players in global sport while positioning itself as the bridge between international sport and international activism.

In that way, F1 can lead by example.

shares
comments
Vettel the right man for Ferrari - Marchionne

Previous article

Vettel the right man for Ferrari - Marchionne

Next article

Pirelli: No tyre compound overhaul in 2015

Pirelli: No tyre compound overhaul in 2015
Load comments
The IndyCar feature that Paul Ricard desperately needs in F1 Prime

The IndyCar feature that Paul Ricard desperately needs in F1

The French Grand Prix offered a surprisingly interesting spectacle, despite the headache-inducing nature of the circuit. But IndyCar's Road America race offered far more in terms of action - and the increased jeopardy at the Elkhart Lake venue might be something Paul Ricard needs in future...

French Grand Prix driver ratings Prime

French Grand Prix driver ratings

The French GP was a weekend decided by tiny margins both at the front of the field, as Red Bull inflicted a comeback defeat on Mercedes, and in the battle for the minor points places. That's reflected in our driver ratings, where several drivers came close to a maximum score

Formula 1
Jun 21, 2021
How Red Bull took French GP "payback" on a day of Mercedes mistakes Prime

How Red Bull took French GP "payback" on a day of Mercedes mistakes

The French GP has been a stronghold for Mercedes since Paul Ricard's return to the calendar in 2018. But that all changed on Sunday, as a clever two-stop strategy guided Red Bull's Max Verstappen to make a race-winning pass on the penultimate lap - for once leaving Mercedes to experience the pain of late defeat it has so often inflicted on Red Bull

Formula 1
Jun 21, 2021
The Mercedes lap that puts F1 victory fight back on a knife-edge Prime

The Mercedes lap that puts F1 victory fight back on a knife-edge

Red Bull led the way after the first two practice sessions for the 2021 French Grand Prix, but only just ahead of Mercedes. There was all the usual practice skulduggery complicating the performance picture, but one aspect seen at the world champion squad gave it a ‘surprise’ lift, as it looks to leave its street-circuit struggles firmly in the past.

Formula 1
Jun 19, 2021
How Ferrari got its F1 recovery plan working Prime

How Ferrari got its F1 recovery plan working

After its worst campaign in 40 years, the famous Italian team had to bounce back in 2021 – and it appears to be delivering. Although it concedes the pole positions in Monaco and Baku paint a somewhat misleading picture of its competitiveness, the team is heading into the 2022 rules revamp on much stronger footing to go for wins again

Formula 1
Jun 18, 2021
The joy that exposes F1’s key weakness Prime

The joy that exposes F1’s key weakness

Long-awaited wins for ex-Formula 1 drivers Marcus Ericsson and Kevin Magnussen in IndyCar and IMSA last weekend gave F1 a reminder of what it is missing. But with the new rules aimed at levelling the playing field, there’s renewed optimism that more drivers can have a rewarding result when their day of days comes

Formula 1
Jun 17, 2021
The F1 figures Red Bull and Mercedes can't afford to see again Prime

The F1 figures Red Bull and Mercedes can't afford to see again

OPINION: An interloper squad got amongst the title contenders during Formula 1’s street-circuit mini-break, where Red Bull left with the points lead in both championships. But, as the campaign heads back to purpose-built venues once again, how the drivers of the two top teams compare in one crucial area will be a major factor in deciding which squad stays in or retakes the top spot

Formula 1
Jun 16, 2021
Why Alfa's boss is up to the task of securing a stronger F1 future Prime

Why Alfa's boss is up to the task of securing a stronger F1 future

Two tenth places in recent races have lifted Alfa Romeo to the head of Formula 1's 'Class C' battle in 2021, but longer-term the Swiss-based squad has far loftier ambitions. With the new 2022 rules set to level out the playing field, team boss Frederic Vasseur has good reason to be optimistic, as he explained to Motorsport.com in an exclusive interview

Formula 1
Jun 15, 2021