Formula 1

Harsh penalty for error-prone McLaren - reaction

GMM

Edited: May 14, 2012, 11:12 PM

Copy link

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

May 13 (GMM) The penalty might be harsh, but the loss of Lewis Hamilton's pole in Spain is just the latest calamitous mistake by McLaren.

That was the tone of the paddock's reaction to the news late on Saturday that a McLaren gaffe saw the FIA send Hamilton from first to last on the Spanish Grand Prix grid.

The Sun newspaper called it a draconian "24-place grid penalty" imposed by the FIA after an "astonishing cock-up" by McLaren.

Hamilton was told on the radio to pull over after his pole lap due to a "technical problem".

Sporting director Sam Michael argued 'force majeure', but the stewards ruled that it had been entirely McLaren's fault that not enough fuel was put into Hamilton's car to ensure a scrutineering fuel sample.

Writing in the Telegraph, Tom Cary said the severity of the disqualification "raised eyebrows", but agreed that "McLaren's mistake was horrendous".

He said it has been "a season of errors" by the famous British team, who are yet to get Hamilton's signature on a new contract beyond 2012.

"Hamilton must be seething," read an article in the Daily Mail newspaper, while The Times laid out McLaren's "catalogue of errors".

27-year-old Hamilton's "raw talent is being thwarted by mishap and cock-up," said journalist Kevin Eason.

"McLaren are lovely people but how the hell do they get themselves in this position?" wrote the Mirror's Byron Young on Twitter.

Even the non-English language media agreed.

"It was another great mistake by McLaren that could eventually cost Hamilton the championship," wrote Livio Oricchio in O Estado de S.Paulo.

Italy's La Stampa called McLaren's fuel gaffe a case of "harakiri".

Germany's Auto Motor und Sport added: "It was error number 13 for McLaren since last year".

While highly critical of McLaren's own-goal, however, the feeling in the paddock is that the stewards' penalty - although accepted by McLaren - was overly harsh.

"Back of the grid? Way, way too harsh", said the Mirror's Young on Twitter.

"Draconian penalty in my view," agreed PA Sport's Ian Parkes. "Dropping Q3 time would have sufficed."

Sky commentator Martin Brundle added: "(I) feel they should have deleted that (Q3) laptime only which would have put him sixth".

And excluding Hamilton from Q3 altogether would have put him 11th. Now, he will be "lucky to score a point", Auto Motor und Sport predicted.

In the Independent, however, David Tremayne noted: "Welcome to the draconian world of F1."

David Croft, the lead Sky commentator, said the FIA stewards had acted correctly.

"A good rule should be one that covers all eventualities with a penalty that acts as a deterrent which in this case is what happened.

"Too little fuel can't be tolerated," he added. "It seems harsh but had Lewis taken pole by one thousandth of a second, would it be harsh then?"

The Spanish fans - not Hamilton's biggest supporters dating back to his spats with Fernando Alonso in 2007 - were happy.

Asked on the El Mundo website whether the penalty was fair, 76 per cent answered yes.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Viber

Previous article Mateschitz, Montezemolo, to join F1 board

Next article Season of confusion to continue on Sunday

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

Latest news

Casey Mears makes milestone 500th NASCAR Cup start he never meant to reach

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup

Homestead-Miami

1 h

Casey Mears makes milestone 500th NASCAR Cup start he never meant to reach

MotoGP Qatar GP: Marco Bezzecchi wins as Marc Marquez has title triumph delayed

MotoGP

MGP MotoGP

Qatar GP

1 h

MotoGP Qatar GP: Marco Bezzecchi wins as Marc Marquez has title triumph delayed

LIVE: F1 Brazilian GP – Lando Norris leads Max Verstappen as rain returns

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

2 h

LIVE: F1 Brazilian GP – Lando Norris leads Max Verstappen as rain returns

WEC Monza: Cadillac wins chaotic finale, #8 Toyota seals drivers’ title

WEC

WEC WEC

Monza

2 h

WEC Monza: Cadillac wins chaotic finale, #8 Toyota seals drivers’ title

Feature

Discover prime content

"He really wanted it" – why Russell was furious over aborted Brazil ‘pole’ lap

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Stuart Codling

"He really wanted it" – why Russell was furious over aborted Brazil ‘pole’ lap

What we learned from Friday practice at the 2026 Brazilian GP

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

What we learned from Friday practice at the 2026 Brazilian GP

How F1’s rules got to be so complex

Formula 1

By Pat Symonds

How F1’s rules got to be so complex

A water park, “not a rock star” and Toto Wolff’s words – Is Kimi Antonelli really a different F1 champion?

Formula 1

By Ronald Vording

A water park, “not a rock star” and Toto Wolff’s words – Is Kimi Antonelli really a different F1 champion?

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Become a subscriber.
Disable your adblocker.

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts