Commentary

Formula 1

Opinion: Why aggregate qualifying would be a disaster for F1

Somehow, Formula 1 finds itself considering an aggregate qualifying system to replace the current one – a move that would make things even worse, argues Jonathan Noble.

Jonathan Noble

Jonathan Noble

Edited: Apr 5, 2016, 8:12 PM

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF16-H

Jean Todt, FIA President

Christian Horner, Red Bull Racing Team Principal and Robert Fernley, Sahara Force India F1 Team Deputy Team Principal

Nico Rosberg, Mercedes AMG F1 Team W07

Bernie Ecclestone

Claire Williams, Williams F1 Team and Dave Ryan, Manor Racing Racing Director

Franz Tost, Scuderia Toro Rosso Team Principal, Christian Horner, Red Bull Racing Team Principal and Robert Fernley, Sahara Force India F1 Team Deputy Team Principal

Niki Lauda, Mercedes Non-Executive Chairman and Maurizio Arrivabene, Ferrari Team Principal

Claire Williams, Williams F1 Team and Dave Ryan, Manor Racing Racing Director

Guenther Steiner, Haas F1 Team Principal with Dave Ryan, Manor Racing Racing Director and Franz Tost, Scuderia Toro Rosso Team Principal

Daniel Ricciardo, Red Bull Racing RB12

Maurizio Arrivabene, Ferrari Team Principal, Franz Tost, Scuderia Toro Rosso Team Principal and Eric Boullier, McLaren Racing Director

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 Team W07

Robert Fernley, Sahara Force India F1 Team Deputy Team Principal and Bernie Ecclestone

Toto Wolff, Mercedes GP Executive Director with the media

Bernie Ecclestone, Jean Todt, FIA President and Christian Horner, Red Bull Racing Team Principal

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 Team W07

Bernie Ecclestone

The lunatics are running the asylum. That was the only logical explanation you could come to over the Bahrain Grand Prix weekend, as F1's insanity about what to do with qualifying reached all-new levels.

For despite the teams, the sport's bosses, the fans, and the drivers all agreeing that the new elimination qualifying format does not work, F1 is now looking at a system that could be even worse.

So bad have the alternatives to the knock-out system been, and so entrenched are some of the political positions that they think going back to the 2015 format is unacceptable, F1 now finds itself looking at an aggregate system that will deliver even more negatives than what we have at the moment.

Aggregate again

Eleven years on from F1 ditching a previous two-session aggregate format that involved race fuel levels, the concept of adding drivers' two best laptimes together has gained some traction because of two key arguments.

The first is that it will ensure cars will be on track more, and the second that it increases the chances of shuffling the order because rather than three perfect laps to take pole position, a driver would need six good laps.

Those supporting the idea claim that the evidence of Bahrain – where Lewis Hamilton had a botched first lap in Q3 – shows that it would mix up the order, because his best two laps would have been good enough for only fourth on the grid.

But that argument is flawed, because Hamilton was not driving to the demands of having to do two laps. Had he needed to deliver an extra quick lap – judging by his brilliance at the end of the session – then there is little reason to think he would not have done it right at the end.

In fact, while aggregate qualifying may have some supporters who think it can serve to deliver more randomness, what is fails to take into account is that the ultra-competitive nature of F1 – allied to the technical direction it has taken – means that what we hope for and what is delivered diverge a great deal.

Economy runs

Asking drivers to deliver two laps may well throw up the idealist view of them being on the ragged edge, trying to be inch perfect for twice as long as they need to now.

But the reality is that teams and drivers will quickly work out exactly how best to maximise the life of tyres and energy recovery systems for whatever distance is called for. It will result in drivers most likely having to rein back on their performance for both laps to operate well within the limits of what the tyres and car are capable of.

Rather than being one lap flat out and the next being about keeping the tyres alive, it will probably be quicker overall to do two laps at 95 percent. That same is true of energy recovery – drivers may have to be economical with battery power to stretch out its deployment best for two laps.

We will no longer have drivers and machines at the absolute limit – as Romain Grosjean made clear on Sunday night.

"I am not a huge fan," he said when I asked him for his views on elimination qualifying. "I spoke with Jenson [Button] and said I don't mind. But yeah, qualifying is the place where in Q3 you have two sets of new tyres so you want to go for the best lap time. With this [aggregate] you can't really push.

"In the past you were doing a good lap time with the first set and then you were putting the new set that you have to give back, so you don't care about the flat spot or whatever. And it was just 'come on: let's go for it!'

"If you have to put two times together, it's not the same. You have to be consistent. The fastest lap time may not be the guy that starts on pole. So who is the lap record holder? I think every driver likes last year's qualifying. That's what we want."

Losing those balls-out laps also means there is less chance of mistakes, so actually less chance of the much-desired jumbled up grid order that prompted the mad push for qualifying changes to start with.

A complicated show

From the driving perspective it is not good, and for the fans in the grandstand and on television it will not be a positive either, and that goes beyond no longer seeing cars going flat out.

To try to follow what drivers are doing over two laps will be hugely complicated for television directors and commentators. For while an aggregate style format works at the Indianapolis 500 – it's a short lap and the cars run alone on track so it's easy to follow track graphics and timing screens – all cars together is a recipe for over-complication.

With so many cars out on track – and none of them necessarily setting best sectors – there will not be much narrative to the session. As it was in 2005, it will not be clear who is fastest or how the battle for pole is shaping up, and in the end all anyone will be watching will be the results rather than what the cars are doing.

The other huge concern is that F1 has got itself in to such a pickle over qualifying that it cannot afford for the next step to be wrong: for anything it introduces from now on will be put under tremendous pressure to produce thrills immediately.

Maximum attack

F1 has been working for more than one year now on delivering cars to make drivers' heroes again, so it seems totally counter-productive to want to take away the prospect of allowing them to push to the maximum on a Saturday.

Lewis Hamilton spoke brilliantly ahead of the Bahrain Grand Prix about the way F1 has lost one of its key elements: the need of drivers to put it on the line every time they get into the car.

At one point he gave a perfect explanation of why not being able to push flat out was not good for racing.

Reflecting on why he could not overtake Max Verstappen's Toro Rosso in Melbourne, he said: "I keep explaining it is like you have $100, and you have to spend it over 40 laps. So if you try to get past that one car and spend $90, then I am not going to make it to the end of the race.

"But people don't care about that: people want to see me race until the end of the race. They want to see me sweat my nuts off to get past and make a fantastic manoeuvre."

For the fans, and the good of the sport, we need the drivers being challenged. And F1 history has shown – especially as we are now in territory of lap records being broken again – that what happens on Saturday when they are on the edge does matter.

Making drivers spread their $100 over two laps with an aggregate system, rather than throw it on an all-or-nothing red or black bet, is not the answer.

**

And if you are interested – what is my solution? If we feel there is a need to really shake things up on a Saturday (which I'm not convinced there is, and we'd be better off going back to the 2015 format and perfecting an elimination format for 2017), then it's a 22-lap qualification race.

Reverse grid based on championship position (leader begins last), start behind safety car and away you go. Last man across the line at the end of each lap is knocked out to make up the grid from the back.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Read also :

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Previous article Haas elects for aggressive Chinese GP tyre strategy

Next article Haas now aiming to score points in every F1 race

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

More from

Jonathan Noble



Brundle awarded OBE in King’s New Year’s honours

Formula 1

Formula 1

Brundle awarded OBE in King’s New Year’s honours



The new rules dilemma that will define the 2025 F1 season

Formula 1

Formula 1

The new rules dilemma that will define the 2025 F1 season



Verstappen issues Red Bull title warning in push for RB21 progress

Formula 1

Formula 1

Australian GP

Verstappen issues Red Bull title warning in push for RB21 progress

Latest news



Oscar Piastri set for grid penalty at F1 Las Vegas GP

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

6 h

Oscar Piastri set for grid penalty at F1 Las Vegas GP



Rodney Childers pushes back on NASCAR CEO's claims about car comparisons

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup 9 h

Rodney Childers pushes back on NASCAR CEO's claims about car comparisons



“He’s beaten Alpine on his own” - Racing Bulls on why it kept Liam Lawson

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

13 h

“He’s beaten Alpine on his own” - Racing Bulls on why it kept Liam Lawson



Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate

Feature

Discover prime content



Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Filip Cleeren

Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate



The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point



What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Stuart Codling

What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?



With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two

Formula 1

By Maurice Hamilton

With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts

Subscribe