Giorgio Piola's F1 technical analysis
Topic

Giorgio Piola's F1 technical analysis

Tech analysis: F1 teams seeking gains in roll-hoop design

Giorgio Piola and Matt Somerfield explain the science behind the intricacies of air-intake design that goes into F1 roll hoops.

Tech analysis: F1 teams seeking gains in roll-hoop design

It is amazing to think that up until 1983, the only part of a Formula 1 car had had to be signed off by a fully-certified engineer was the roll-over safety bar.

Advances in car safety (plus ever tougher crash tests) have come thick and fast since then – but it is interesting to see that what was once an area of the car only there to protect drivers is now being exploited like never before to also find performance.

The Mercedes W07's airbox is one of the largest in the 2016 field but, it is not the first time we have seen teams use this area and the roll hoop in different ways to achieve both structural and aerodynamic goals.

While structural integrity is clearly paramount, as the roll hoop provides the driver with protection in the case of an accident, it is the aerodynamic advantage that can be leveraged that is of the utmost importance.

Mercedes pushes the boundaries

Mercedes W01 air intake evolution
Mercedes W01 air intake evolution

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

It is not the first time that Mercedes has pushed the envelope in this area.

From the 2010 Spanish Grand Prix (above right), it used a bladed roll solution that allowed a multitude of options in terms of supplying airflow from the airbox inlets to the engine, be it for combustion or ancillary coolers. 

Force India VJM04 air intake
Force India VJM04 air intake

Illustration by: Giorgio Piola

In 2011, Force India (above) ran a similar solution to that of Mercedes from 2010, which had returned to a more conventional solution by then.

The VJM04 used snorkels mounted either side of the roll blade, which provided air to the Mercedes FO 108Y V8 engine.

With teams getting more extreme with their designs in this area – even if they had passed crash test – the FIA elected to clamp down on what teams could do for 2012 onwards.

New power units, new requirements

Toro Rosso STR9 air intake
Toro Rosso STR9 air intake

Illustration by: Giorgio Piola

The new roll-hoop rules, allied to some experimenting at the time with F-ducts, led to teams exploring other areas before the switch to the hybrid V6 turbocharged power units in 2014 brought this area of the car sharply back into focus.

The increased need to supply air to not only the turbo's compressor but also a vast array of radiators and air-to-air coolers meant it was important again.

Toro Rosso (above) decided to use an enlarged airbox, supplementing the conventional upper inlet with another below it.

Big developments in 2015

2015 air intakes comparison
2015 air intakes comparison

Illustration by: Giorgio Piola

In 2015, having previously used 'ears' on the side of its predecessor's roll hoops, Lotus (above, main image) opted to fully integrate them into its design.

The tri-inlet divided airflow with the turbo compressor fed by the main, larger inlet whist the two smaller inlets fed various ERS coolers and a gearbox oil cooler.

The large inlet being used by Mercedes, like those that have gone before it, compartmentalizes the airflow, with the central inlet supplying airflow to the turbo's compressor, while the outer inlets supply air to cool ancillary coolers.

The importance of maintaining the thermal operating window is critical, as each of the power unit elements needs to stay within a very narrow temperature band in order to maximize efficiency and performance.

As the manufacturers and fuel suppliers continue to push the combustion envelope, it becomes imperative that the correct ratio of fuel and air is supplied, and that pre detonation doesn't occur, as this scuppers reliability, performance and efficiency.

Mercedes' latest solution

Mercedes W07 airbox details
Mercedes W07 airbox details

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

During pre-season testing Mercedes furnished the W07's airbox with Kiel probes, measuring the airflow being received to ensure it was at the right level in all the channels.

This information was used to correlate the real world data with what the team expected, having completed CFD and the windtunnel tests.

shares
comments

FIA widens scope of Formula 1 radio clampdown

Aston Martin set for Red Bull F1 deal

How F1's new era has exposed the downside of its most important rule

How F1's new era has exposed the downside of its most important rule

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
Jonathan Noble

How F1's new era has exposed the downside of its most important rule How F1's new era has exposed the downside of its most important rule

Why Piastri’s F1 homecoming will be a landmark occasion

Why Piastri’s F1 homecoming will be a landmark occasion

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
Australian GP
GP Racing

Why Piastri’s F1 homecoming will be a landmark occasion Why Piastri’s F1 homecoming will be a landmark occasion

The recent Australian GP form history that will boost Ferrari in F1 2023

The recent Australian GP form history that will boost Ferrari in F1 2023

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
Australian GP
Alex Kalinauckas

The recent Australian GP form history that will boost Ferrari in F1 2023 The recent Australian GP form history that will boost Ferrari in F1 2023

The cycle of F1 upheaval Williams must end to rediscover past glories

The cycle of F1 upheaval Williams must end to rediscover past glories

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
GP Racing

The cycle of F1 upheaval Williams must end to rediscover past glories The cycle of F1 upheaval Williams must end to rediscover past glories

The state of play in F1's technical silly season

The state of play in F1's technical silly season

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
Jake Boxall-Legge

The state of play in F1's technical silly season The state of play in F1's technical silly season

Ranking the top 10 pre-war grand prix drivers

Ranking the top 10 pre-war grand prix drivers

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
Kevin Turner

Ranking the top 10 pre-war grand prix drivers Ranking the top 10 pre-war grand prix drivers

Why drivers are the least of Ferrari’s F1 worries

Why drivers are the least of Ferrari’s F1 worries

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
GP Racing

Why drivers are the least of Ferrari’s F1 worries Why drivers are the least of Ferrari’s F1 worries

How Vasseur has begun Ferrari’s mission to keep Leclerc on side

How Vasseur has begun Ferrari’s mission to keep Leclerc on side

Prime
Prime
Formula 1
GP Racing

How Vasseur has begun Ferrari’s mission to keep Leclerc on side How Vasseur has begun Ferrari’s mission to keep Leclerc on side