Formula 1 Qatar GP

Why Hamilton's Losail and Norris's Jeddah false starts were treated differently

There is sound reasoning behind why Hamilton was penalised for a false start in Qatar when Norris was cleared of any wrongdoing earlier in the season

Ewan Gale

Published: Dec 4, 2024, 3:15 PM

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Fernando Alonso, Aston Martin AMR24, Kevin Magnussen, Haas VF-24, Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W15, Valtteri Bottas, KICK Sauber C44, the remainder of the field

Fernando Alonso, Aston Martin AMR24, Kevin Magnussen, Haas VF-24, Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W15, Valtteri Bottas, KICK Sauber C44, the remainder of the field

Photo by: Andy Hone / Motorsport Images

Lewis Hamilton was penalised at the Qatar Grand Prix for a false start having moved - and then stopped - before the lights went out to begin the race.

The Mercedes driver picked up his first penalty of a trying race when he nudged forward early, though his loss of momentum as he tried to correct the error saw him lose spots off the line.

Seven-time world champion Hamilton was downcast after the race when holding his hands up for the error, as well as his later penalty for speeding in the pits, saying: "It could have been worse, but I finished and it's over.

"That was me at the start. And then the puncture was really unfortunate. And the pitlane, that was me as well. I'll do my best, but I'll get back up tomorrow and give it another shot."

But the consistency of penalty application had arisen on social media amid the debate around the FIA's decision-making at the Losail International Circuit, with some pointing to Lando Norris's lack of punishment for a similar misjudgement at the start at this year's Saudi Arabian Grand Prix.

So why was Hamilton punished and Norris wasn't?

What did Norris do?

At the second round in Jeddah, Norris did almost the exact same thing as Hamilton had done in nudging forward in his grid box before the lights extinguished, before stopping and then getting going with a loss of momentum.

The 'false start' was noted by Hamilton's Mercedes team-mate George Russell, who was straight onto his team radio to call "false start Norris" as he breezed by the McLaren.

But it transpired that Norris had failed to trigger the FIA transponder at the start, meaning that because of the absence of an alert from the sensor, he was spared a penalty.

Lando Norris, McLaren MCL38, George Russell, Mercedes F1 W15, Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W15, Lance Stroll, Aston Martin AMR24, Yuki Tsunoda, RB F1 Team VCARB 01, the remainder of the field at the start

Lando Norris, McLaren MCL38, George Russell, Mercedes F1 W15, Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W15, Lance Stroll, Aston Martin AMR24, Yuki Tsunoda, RB F1 Team VCARB 01, the remainder of the field at the start

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

The stewards's report at the event read: "The Stewards reviewed positioning/marshalling system data, video and determined that the video appeared to show that Car 4 moved before the start signal was given.

"However, the FIA-approved and supplied transponder fitted on the car did not indicate a jump start. Article 48.1 a) of the Formula One Sporting Regulations states clearly that the judgment of whether or not there was a jump start is to be made in accordance with the transponder, which did not show a jump start. In the circumstances, we took no further action."

What was different for Hamilton?

As the stewards's report states from the past weekend: "The FIA transponder indicated a false start. This was confirmed by examination of the video evidence from the on-board camera of Car 44.  As the start of Car 44 was only very slightly ahead of the start signal, the minimum penalty is applied."

The fact the transponder was triggered is the first point of difference between the two incidents, even though they look near-identical. But in truth, Hamilton was more likely to be penalised anyway, given a major change to the regulations following discussions at the F1 Commission meeting held between the Chinese and Australian Grands Prix.

Read Also:

Confusion over Norris's non-penalty, given it was obvious to the eye that there was a false start, led to a change in the wording of the regulations, with the sentence that determined any jumps could be found only by the transponder being triggered removed from the rulebook.

A revision to Article 48.1 a) of the Sporting Regulations instead states than an offence will be deemed to have taken place if a driver is judged to have: "moved after the four (4) second light is illuminated and before the start signal is given by extinguishing all red lights."

Therefore, regardless of Hamilton's transponder being triggered on Sunday, the Briton would have been punished under the revised regulation anyway.

This was no inconsistency from the FIA or the race stewards, but rather all parties learning from a confusing situation and putting things right.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Read also :

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Previous article Arthur Leclerc to join brother Charles at Ferrari for Abu Dhabi FP1

Next article Why Zandvoort is giving up on F1 before Verstappen

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

More from

Ewan Gale



Tsolov named Red Bull, Racing Bulls reserve driver after missing out on 2027 F1 race seat

Formula 1

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

Tsolov named Red Bull, Racing Bulls reserve driver after missing out on 2027 F1 race seat



Cadillac to investigate high-speed Mexico GP failure that led to angry Valtteri Bottas reaction

Formula 1

Formula 1

Mexican GP

Cadillac to investigate high-speed Mexico GP failure that led to angry Valtteri Bottas reaction



Sergio Perez praises Colton Herta impact - but has no say over 2027 Cadillac F1 team-mate choice

Formula 1

Formula 1

Mexican GP

Sergio Perez praises Colton Herta impact - but has no say over 2027 Cadillac F1 team-mate choice

More from

Lando Norris



"We haven't taken any steps backwards" – McLaren boss explains 2026

Formula 1

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

20 h

"We haven't taken any steps backwards" – McLaren boss explains 2026



Lando Norris: F1 needs better rain tyres as wet Las Vegas would be "scary"

Formula 1

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

Lando Norris: F1 needs better rain tyres as wet Las Vegas would be "scary"



How Lando Norris prevailed in a swift errors tour of Interlagos

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

How Lando Norris prevailed in a swift errors tour of Interlagos

Latest news



Rafael Camara torn between his F2 title bid and more F1 races with Haas

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

8 min

Rafael Camara torn between his F2 title bid and more F1 races with Haas



F1 Mexico GP fallout was “taken out of proportion” - Charles Leclerc

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

57 min

F1 Mexico GP fallout was “taken out of proportion” - Charles Leclerc



Honda reveals key F1 power unit change for 2027

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

2 h

Honda reveals key F1 power unit change for 2027



Max Verstappen on F1's WHOOP plan: "It's nobody's business, I don't even know my heart rate"

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

3 h

Max Verstappen on F1's WHOOP plan: "It's nobody's business, I don't even know my heart rate"

Feature

Discover prime content



Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s

Formula 1

By Kevin Turner

Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s



Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Filip Cleeren

Racing Bulls insists that keeping "immense" Lawson doesn't contradict its mandate



The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point



What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Stuart Codling

What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts

Subscribe