What IndyCar fans want

The Firestone 550 at Texas has started a lot of conversation in the motorsports world.

What IndyCar fans want

In the movie What Women Want, Mel Gibson plays a womanizing advertising executive accidentally gifted with the ability to read women’s thoughts. This allows him to tailor his advertising proposals to a core female demographic that had eluded him. If only the elite at INDYCAR and IMS had the same gift. The Firestone 550 at Texas Motor Speedway certainly sparked debate on not only the core demographic, but also on the product itself. The issue facing the IZOD IndyCar Series could be made into a movie: What IndyCar Fans Want.

In an interview with Curt Cavin of the Indianapolis Star published on June 10, Mark Miles, Hulman & Co. CEO, acknowledged that the Indianapolis 500 needs to provide more entertainment during the month of May than is currently offered. Whether that means more on-track activity, concerts, or other entertainment options was not clear. What was clear is that something needs to change to attract more fans to the venue. The rub is determining exactly what those changes need to be. It is also clear that the racing in the IZOD IndyCar Series suffers from a similar public perception issue. What do IndyCar fans really want?

Mark Miles
Mark Miles

Photo by: Anne Proffit

One type of IndyCar fan abhors the fact the series has spec cars. This fan absolutely knows the solution is to open up development. This open development would allow the teams with the most money to spend their way to victory. In the good old days of packed venues, these rich teams dominated the podium race after race, often winning by wide margins with only two or three cars on the same lap. In this fan’s mind, it makes perfect sense. If the series goes back to the way it was, then the crowds will follow. This post hoc, ergo propter hoc (after this, therefore because of this) argument connects crowds to differentiation. Of course, running all the small teams out of the series because they cannot afford to be competitive in the current economy may not be the best course of action.

Another category is the hard-core fan. The mantra is always the same. If everyone worshiped at the altar of history, and the series and IMS promoted how wonderful the roadsters were, then fans would flock to see the modern incarnations of Bill Vukovich and Wilbur Shaw. I fit in this category, and as much as I love the timeline of auto innovation that the history of IndyCar racing gives us, it is not enough to interest a new generation of fans not weened on the car culture of my youth. Cars may be cool to them, but the history of cars is not. History is full of martyrs who were willing to sacrifice all to prove a point. The hard-core fans need to open their eyes and see that neither history nor martyrdom will save the series.

Lets not forget the fan who says the series almost has it right. We just need a few tweaks here and there. If only aero kits were adopted, then it would create a difference, both aerodynamically and aesthetically, that the fans would love without breaking the bank for the teams. The downside could be racing like we saw at Texas Motor Speedway recently when Helio Castroneves had a lead of half a lap with no competition. Now that’s racing like it used to be: a few cars on the lead lap with very little passing for the lead. Derrick Walker, the new president of competition for the IZOD IndyCar Series, just tweaked the aero rules a little bit at Texas and changed the racing completely. These fans need to remember the law of unintended consequences.

A fan
A fan

Photo by: Eric Gilbert

Some fans and owners say that all the series needs is a better TV package with more enthusiastic announcers. They believe the broadcast partners need to promote the venues, TV productions, and the series better. Maybe the movie Turbo with its action figures and video games will be the catalyst that brings more viewers to the broadcasts and allows IndyCar to reach a new demographic. Without a doubt, the TV ratings drive investment in the series.

A set of fans believe that races need carnival barkers, amusement rides, and the assorted freaks and geeks that go along with this. Maybe it is the local promoters who need to succeed for the series to grow. If the races make money for the promoter, then the series can worry more about the myriad of other issues that it faces. Even though the racing in the series is as good as it has ever been, the consumer at the venue demands to be entertained at all times.

Another fan screams that it is all about the future. This fan says find out what someone needs to become a new fan and do that thing, tradition be damned. They use the quote “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.” IndyCar has certainly had plenty of that.

The movie What Women Want follows a typical romcom storyline. Mel Gibson’s character acts selfishly, loses true love, repents, and gains the love of his life. Like most movies of this genre, it has a predictable happy ending. The saga of the IZOD IndyCar Series may not have the same story arc. Mark Miles, who seems to understand that change is needed, has not been given the gift to know what all IndyCar fans, current and future, are thinking, yet he must decide the course of the series for years to come based on his perceptions. After he is through with the fans, maybe he can figure out what the owners, drivers, sponsors, and TV partners want. If he can do that, then the Academy Award is his.

New Track Record

Castroneves and Penske dance away from justice at Texas post-race inspection

Previous article

Castroneves and Penske dance away from justice at Texas post-race inspection

Next article

Remembering Jason Leffler

Remembering Jason Leffler
Load comments

About this article

Series IndyCar
Drivers Helio Castroneves , Eric Gilbert , Bill Vukovich
Author Mark Wilkinson
Why IndyCar's new aero parts should improve racing at Indy Prime

Why IndyCar's new aero parts should improve racing at Indy

Tino Belli, IndyCar’s director of aerodynamic development, believes the changes to the underside of the cars will allow them to run closer at Indy and make passes. The moment of truth comes on its biggest stage, writes David Malsher-Lopez.

Colton Herta – America's next racing hero Prime

Colton Herta – America's next racing hero

Last Sunday, Colton Herta demolished his IndyCar opposition in the second round of the season. David Malsher-Lopez explains why Andretti Autosport’s youngest ace bears all the hallmarks of becoming the country’s next homegrown motorsport hero.

Apr 29, 2021
How good is Palou and is he Dixon’s strongest title rival? Prime

How good is Palou and is he Dixon’s strongest title rival?

Last Sunday, Alex Palou delivered his first IndyCar victory on his Chip Ganassi Racing debut. Is the young Spaniard going to become his legendary teammate Scott Dixon’s biggest title threat? David Malsher-Lopez reports.

Apr 21, 2021
Preview: Why IndyCar in 2021 is too close to call Prime

Preview: Why IndyCar in 2021 is too close to call

The fight for supremacy in the NTT IndyCar Series will be as intense as ever. David Malsher-Lopez is your guide to the main contenders and six intriguing sub-plots.

Apr 15, 2021
Is Arrow McLaren SP ready for IndyCar’s title fight? Prime

Is Arrow McLaren SP ready for IndyCar’s title fight?

With Patricio O'Ward and Felix Rosenqvist leading its line-up, 2021 could be the year Arrow McLaren SP-Chevrolet joins the IndyCar elite, writes David Malsher-Lopez.

Feb 21, 2021
Dale Coyne picks the Top 10 drivers in his giant-slaying team Prime

Dale Coyne picks the Top 10 drivers in his giant-slaying team

Over 37 seasons, Dale Coyne has run no fewer than 80 Indy car drivers – including himself! Ahead of his first season running Romain Grosjean, we asked Coyne to pick the best 10 drivers ever to compete for him. By David Malsher-Lopez.

Feb 10, 2021
Why enigmatic Marco Andretti will be missed Prime

Why enigmatic Marco Andretti will be missed

Last Friday, Marco Andretti announced he is withdrawing from fulltime IndyCar racing. David Malsher-Lopez explains how this third-gen racer was a puzzle in the car, but a straight shooter off-track.

Jan 19, 2021
Why Roger Penske is an American motorsport icon Prime

Why Roger Penske is an American motorsport icon

In this exclusive one-on-one interview, Roger Penske reveals the inner drive that has made him not only a hugely successful team owner and businessman but also the owner of Indianapolis Motor Speedway and IndyCar. He spoke to David Malsher-Lopez.

Dec 28, 2020