Opinion
Formula 1 United States GP
McLaren's deja vu moment should spell the end of its F1 driver "repercussions"
After the latest racing incident involving Oscar Piastri and Lando Norris in Formula 1's United States Grand Prix sprint race in Austin, McLaren faces the question of whether it should keep controlling the uncontrollable
Filip Cleeren
Edited: Oct 19, 2025, 12:46 AM
Copy link
Share on Viber
Lando Norris, McLaren crash
Photo by: Jim Watson / AFP via Getty Images
A McLaren driver taking a healthy dose of risk at the start of a race, making contact with a third party and then swiping his team-mate. Sound familiar?
The start of Austin's sprint race bore an uncanny resemblance to the start of the Singapore Grand Prix two weeks ago, except this time the roles were reversed and the consequences were more impactful, as Piastri's contact with Norris ended both of their races and handed eight free points to emerging title contender Max Verstappen.
That's not to say Piastri committed a huge mistake in Austin, far from it. But making such a cutback at COTA's steep and wide Turn 1 is risky business, with a guarantee that at least one car will be trying to lunge down the inside. Was Piastri too focused on defeating his own team-mate to take that classic scenario into account?
Read Also:
Bad news - it wasn't one but two cars, as Nico Hulkenberg was sandwiched by both the Australian and Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso, leaving the German with nowhere to go as the contact triggered a shower of carbon fibre. It made McLaren CEO Zak Brown's instant finger pointing at Hulkenberg a bit of a head scratcher, as much as it is his duty to protect his own drivers.
(Update - Brown later retracted his "heat of the moment" comments on Sky Sports, saying "I don't think that's on Nico.")
The fairest verdict for the Texan Turn 1 rodeo is a racing incident, but if you are leading the championship it's sometimes better to be safe than right. There were still 19 laps to hound Norris, and both McLarens had a good shot of defeating an only moderately fast Verstappen rather than gifting him more points.
Again, this is not intended to be a stick to beat Piastri with. The point is that if you're Lando Norris and you're watching the replays, surely you'll be wondering if this is a very similar scenario to Singapore, which the Briton then faced undisclosed "repercussions" for.
Are those consequences - whether it's related to qualifying order priority or something else - now going to be undone? Reversed?
Photo by: Sam Bloxham / LAT Images via Getty Images
Arguably, the correct answer is that Piastri doesn't deserve any repercussions at all, and neither did Norris. Because he was trying to win a motor race, he raced the cars around him hard but fair and in the process made a slight misjudgement, as did Norris two weeks ago. Contact with your team-mate is motor racing's cardinal sin, but sometimes that just happens.
In fairness to McLaren, it does deserve more sympathy than people seem to extend at this stage of the season. Yes, there are nine competitors who would love to be in the position of the recently crowned constructors' champion and its luxury problem right now. But the squad has thus far managed to have two number one drivers vie for the world title without them wanting to take each other's head off or make a beeline for the McLaren Technology Centre's large glass exit doors.
That is an admirable, rare feat in F1. Unheard of, really. And it is great for neutrals that Norris and Piastri are both able to chase their own title aspirations without the team backing one over the other prematurely.
But the spectre of its ill-advised Monza position swap keeps hanging over the team, with it now painting itself into a corner to keep righting any wrongs, trying to control the uncontrollable of F1's fastest-ever generation of cars racing at the edge of adhesion. And all that man-management keeps dominating the conversation rather than the racing itself.
By trying not to interfere it feels like McLaren has interfered too much.
With the counterbalancing drama of Singapore and Austin's sprint out of the way, can Norris and Piastri now just get on with it?
Photos from United States GP - Saturday
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
United States GP - Saturday, in photos
Formula 1
59
Read Also:
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?
Take our 5 minute survey.
- The Motorsport.com Team
Read and post comments
Read also :
Share Or Save This Story
Copy link
Share on Viber
Previous article Lance Stroll handed US GP penalty after Esteban Ocon sprint race crash
Next article LIVE: F1 US GP updates - Max Verstappen takes pole position from Lando Norris, Oscar Piastri sixth
Top Comments
There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?
View More & Comment
More from
Filip Cleeren
Five key takeaways from F1's big African Grand Prix reveal in Rwanda
Formula 1
Formula 1
Five key takeaways from F1's big African Grand Prix reveal in Rwanda
F1 signs historic 10-year Rwanda deal to host African Grand Prix
Formula 1
Formula 1
F1 signs historic 10-year Rwanda deal to host African Grand Prix
More from
Lando Norris
Why McLaren cannot fix its F1 car handling until 2027
Formula 1
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Why McLaren cannot fix its F1 car handling until 2027
Andrea Stella praises Lando Norris for reaction to Singapore GP sprint clash
Formula 1
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Andrea Stella praises Lando Norris for reaction to Singapore GP sprint clash
More from
McLaren
The six drivers doing double duty in Portimao GTWCE and Barcelona WEC this weekend
WEC
WEC
Barcelona
The six drivers doing double duty in Portimao GTWCE and Barcelona WEC this weekend
Oscar Piastri on his Singapore puncture: “Ironically, it probably helped”
Formula 1
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Oscar Piastri on his Singapore puncture: “Ironically, it probably helped”
Latest news
Ryan Blaney kind of faces a must-win scenario this weekend at Phoenix
NASCAR Cup
NAS NASCAR Cup
Phoenix II
8 min
Ryan Blaney kind of faces a must-win scenario this weekend at Phoenix
Catching Larson in the NASCAR Chase has to start at track where 'I suck'
NASCAR Cup
NAS NASCAR Cup
Phoenix II
1 h
Catching Larson in the NASCAR Chase has to start at track where 'I suck'
Verstappen charges from 24th to ninth as GetSpeed wins Portimao GTWC finale
GT World Challenge Europe Endurance
WCEE GT World Challenge Europe Endurance 2 h
Verstappen charges from 24th to ninth as GetSpeed wins Portimao GTWC finale
Colton Herta “maybe underestimated the difference” from IndyCar – F2 boss
FIA F2
F2 FIA F2 6 h
Colton Herta “maybe underestimated the difference” from IndyCar – F2 boss
Feature
Discover prime content
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
You have 2 options:
- Become a subscriber.
- Disable your adblocker.
Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here
Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page
Manage Alerts
Subscribe