Hurtgen/LeDuc XE crash "not accident waiting to happen"

The Extreme E crash between Claudia Hurtgen and Kyle LeDuc that red flagged the shootout race was “not an accident waiting to happen” despite weekend-long concerns over dust. 

After Veloce Racing pulled out of the Desert X-Prix in Saudi Arabia following irreparable roll cage damage, only the Chip Ganassi Racing and Abt Cupra entries contested the shootout. 

In the second half of the race to decide positions seventh and eighth, Ganassi driver Kyle LeDuc was chasing down Abt Cupra’s Claudia Hurtgen when the pair collided heavily.  

Heading down a hill, where Hurtgen rolled the car four times on Saturday, LeDuc hit some ridges that unsettled the car. He emerged from the dust trail behind Hurtgen and they collided. 

Both teams’ crew had worked into Saturday night, with Abt Cupra completing a 23-hour shift, following Hurtgen’s shunt and persistent power steering issues for Ganassi. 

Ganassi team principal Dave Berkenfield told Motorsport.com: “Both of them walked away and they're all OK. They took their knocks and took their licks. But man that racing was exciting, I have to admit.  

“As long as we can do that entertainment in a safe manner, in a competitive manner, that's how this series is going to survive.” 

This collision came after the event format had already been revised, with four- and five-car qualifying heats dropped in favour of one-car time trials due to excessive dust. 

Berkenfield added that the shunt had not been expected, despite onboard video footage showing that LeDuc had very limited visibility when running behind Hurtgen.  

“I don't think that was an accident waiting to happen,” he said. 

“Passing in the desert, you’ve got to practice it. You’ve got to be comfortable with it and you’ve got to be bold. 

“You’ve got to be able to read terrain and drive within yourself a little bit and be measured. 

“I don't think that you could push what we've seen here into the next events. The racing lines are going to be different; the racing is going to be different.” 

Read Also:

Hurtgen explained to Motorsport.com that she had slowed over the ridges that disturbed LeDuc’s car, which led to the impact, and said the bumps had developed overnight. 

“I come down the hill and there was a big bump, so I have to release the throttle,” she said. “Then I released the throttle the other guy hit me.  

“OK, so I think he cannot see and the bumps were new - yesterday there were no bumps. “But I had to go off the throttle and in this moment, he hit me flat out.” 

She added that she “cannot understand” LeDuc’s attempted pass. 

“We are not fighting for the championship, only for position seven. There’s enough space to go right or left on the lines.

"Also, there’s a slow corner you can accelerate out of there. I cannot understand it.” 

shares
comments

Related video

Rosberg X Racing, Andretti United win Extreme E semi-finals

Previous article

Rosberg X Racing, Andretti United win Extreme E semi-finals

Next article

Rosberg's team dominates Extreme E's Saudi opener

Rosberg's team dominates Extreme E's Saudi opener
Load comments

About this article

Series Extreme E
Event Desert X-Prix
Author Matt Kew
How Extreme E exceeded expectations to pass its first major test Prime

How Extreme E exceeded expectations to pass its first major test

The racing may have lacked the explosive conclusion to Formula E's first race in 2014 and was not without its hiccups. But Extreme E's leap into the unknown appears to have paid off, delivering a spectacle quite unlike anything else

Extreme E
Apr 5, 2021
Extreme E: The team-by-team guide Prime

Extreme E: The team-by-team guide

The world’s newest motorsport discipline is set to go racing for the first time this weekend. Extreme E’s innovations and plans have raised some eyebrows, but it also provides an exciting list of competitors and teams for the inaugural campaign

Extreme E
Apr 2, 2021
How Extreme E’s charging solution could transform motorsport Prime

How Extreme E’s charging solution could transform motorsport

The new off-road SUV series aims to go boldly into the unknown on several fronts, but perhaps its most significant measure will involve the energy source powering its fleet of cars

Extreme E
Apr 1, 2021
How XE's star power puts Formula E under pressure Prime

How XE's star power puts Formula E under pressure

With the addition of Jenson Button's own team to join the involvement of fellow Formula 1 champions Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg in Extreme E's ranks, the new electric SUV series is brimming with star power to enable it to deliver on its promise

Extreme E
Jan 29, 2021
Driving the electric beast behind XE’s off-road eco-crusade Prime

Driving the electric beast behind XE’s off-road eco-crusade

In October, Motorsport.com headed to the South of France to sample the Odyssey 21 - the titanic 550bhp machine underpinning Alejandro Agag's latest electric venture. But for such a big beast, it's a nimble machine that should provide spectacular entertainment…

Extreme E
Dec 10, 2020
Why a fearsome ‘electric alliance’ will have lasting significance Prime

Why a fearsome ‘electric alliance’ will have lasting significance

OPINION: Formula E has invested in Extreme E to create a formal allegiance between the two most influential electric motorsport series. Allaying fears of financial uncertainty, together they will shape the future of battery-powered motorsport competition…

Formula E
Nov 4, 2020
Why latest Hamilton-Rosberg battle won’t have the same edge Prime

Why latest Hamilton-Rosberg battle won’t have the same edge

Even four years after it ended, the rivalry between Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg has yet to be topped for drama and intrigue by anything F1 has seen since. But the next iteration commencing in 2021 will played out on much different terms...

Extreme E
Oct 30, 2020
How the new electric series with planet-changing aims will work Prime

How the new electric series with planet-changing aims will work

The new off-road electric race series from the people who brought you Formula E has no less an aim than saving the world’s most at-risk habitats. Here’s who things are set to get underway in 2021

Extreme E
Jan 14, 2020