Banned: How F1 finally overcame blown floor trickery

The FIA has to constantly adjust the regulations to reign in teams as they find new and interesting ways in which to defeat the spirit of the rules in the quest for better laptimes.

Banned: How F1 finally overcame blown floor trickery

In the lead-up to the 2012 season, the governing body had made numerous changes to fight against the growing trend of using the exhaust to affect the car's aerodynamic output.

This had followed the ban on double diffusers, which had subsequently been enhanced in their second year by the use of exhaust blowing solutions which the FIA also made an attempt at stopping.

As we explained last week, the clampdown wasn't effective and in fact the tighter restrictions actually led to the practice mushrooming. But, with particularly stringent dimensional criteria being put in place for 2012, it was hoped the sport could move on.

However, with blown floors being such a good avenue for increasing car performance, designers were not going to sit back and let any opportunity pass them by.

The 'Coanda' effect

McLaren MP4-27 'Semi-Coanda' exhaust solution

McLaren MP4-27 'Semi-Coanda' exhaust solution

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

McLaren introduced a solution that was most widely adopted for 2012, utilizing the exhaust plume to leverage the 'Coanda effect,' This was where the jet of exhaust gas expelled from the engine pulled nearby airflow towards it, and together would alter the overall trajectory of the exhaust's energetic flow regime.

Read Also:

This would result in it being driven toward the gap between the tyre's sidewall and the diffuser's outer wall, just as it was with the exhaust blown diffuser solutions used in 2011.

The critical thinking behind the design of the McLaren solution was that with the exhaust mounted in a pod that overhung the sidepod, airflow would still flow around the sidepod and into the coke bottle region.

Sauber C31 'Coanda' exhaust ramp

Sauber C31 'Coanda' exhaust ramp

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

This was a key issue that the users of a ramp down solution, such as Sauber shown here, had to wrestle with. For the exhaust plume would mix with the flow ordinarily destined for the coke bottle region - diluting the effect of both.

Adrian Newey was having none of this though. He'd already convinced himself that the McLaren style solution was inelegant and that the full ramp configuration was not going to cut it either. He needed that coke bottle flow to remain uninterrupted, and so set about finding a way to reclaim it.

Red Bull's search for a solution that would offer the best of both worlds was much more complex and would utilise a crossover tunnel. This would not come without its complications though, as the team grappled with trying to make it work in the real world after simulations offered some promising potential.

Red Bull RB8 original exhaust solution exiting under upper wishbone, arrows depict predicted exhaust plume trajectory

Red Bull RB8 original exhaust solution exiting under upper wishbone, arrows depict predicted exhaust plume trajectory
1/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

So convinced was Red Bull that it was onto something special, it actually ran a benign exhaust solution through the course of pre-season testing in an effort to delay anyone being able to copy its arrangement.

Red Bull RB8 changes to floor, additional slot (highlighted in yellow) allows exhaust plume to enter diffuser earlier

Red Bull RB8 changes to floor, additional slot (highlighted in yellow) allows exhaust plume to enter diffuser earlier
2/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

It finally unveiled its crossover ramp solution on the penultimate day of testing, and duly came up against issues, as it suddenly found it had flow instability with the tunnel that made the car inconsistent on turn-in. But an almost unwavering belief that it was the right way to go rather than McLaren's idea led to an intense development phase for Red Bull.

Red Bull RB8 'Coanda' exhaust ramp comparison

Red Bull RB8 'Coanda' exhaust ramp comparison
3/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

The regulatory changes for 2012 not only had an impact on the position of the exhaust but also the surrounding bodywork. As such, many of the designs seen up and down the grid that used this Coanda-style solution had bodywork with a trough-like appearance. Dimensionally this was bounded by the new regulations and most opted for a simple letterbox style trough. However, Red Bull pursued numerous ways of manipulating this shape to influence the trajectory of the exhaust plume and tried different solutions, some of which hoped to manipulate flow into the tunnel beneath.

Red Bull RB8 exhaust solution favoured by Vettel

Red Bull RB8 exhaust solution favoured by Vettel
4/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

For the Chinese GP, Sebastian Vettel even reverted to the pre-season testing solution, as he not only felt it might arrest some of the issues he was having with the car but also help the team understand where those issues might lie.

Red Bull RB8 floor protested, small slot for legality (right inset)

Red Bull RB8 floor protested, small slot for legality (right inset)
5/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

A hole in this position, rather than a slot, was more aerodynamically potent, so the other teams believed its use by Red Bull was a deliberate infringement on the technical regulations. You'll also note at this point that Red Bull had changed the point at which airflow from the crossover tunnel had been moved (see right inset for initial exit), with flow now exiting further down the car.

Red Bull RB8 sidepod and exhaust changes (twin cross-under tunnel in new specification, old spec inset)

Red Bull RB8 sidepod and exhaust changes (twin cross-under tunnel in new specification, old spec inset)
6/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

The tinkering continued, now with a renewed effort being made to reshape the crossover tunnel's entrance in order to smooth the passage of airflow into the tunnel and beyond. This meant a total redesign of the sidepod, including the movement of the exhaust tailpipe. There was also a lengthening of the tunnel, the shape of the tunnel's entrance being enlarged and a vertical separating slot mounted within.

Red Bull RB8 sidepod amendments, yellow line dictates shape change around 'Coanda' ramp to influence direction of exhaust plume

Red Bull RB8 sidepod amendments, yellow line dictates shape change around 'Coanda' ramp to influence direction of exhaust plume
7/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

At this point it appeared that the team had finally got on top of its aerodynamic instability issues and the car behaved more predictably, meaning it could now hunt for extra performance. This would come from a continued push to refine the crossover tunnels and bodywork that surrounded the exhaust's shape and a renewed effort by Renault to find ways to stabilise the exhaust flow. You'll note that the shape of the sidepod bodywork around the exhaust would change from trying to influence flow into the tunnel to a section that protected the two flow regimes from one another.

Red Bull RB8 exhaust detail, note use of 'Helmholtz' resonance chamber (alterations made to original specification, inset)

Red Bull RB8 exhaust detail, note use of 'Helmholtz' resonance chamber (alterations made to original specification, inset)
8/8

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

Meanwhile, the team had worked out that the plume created by the exhaust's shape, itself mandated by the new regulations, was having a detrimental effect. In order to soften a damaging vortex that was being formed, it worked on using a Helmholtz resonance chamber. The amount of work done by Red Bull during 2012 to make its solutions work was monumental but that's not to say others on the grid were resting on their laurels either.
Sauber C31 'Coanda' exhaust ramp
Sauber C31 'Coanda' exhaust ramp

 

 

Sauber, which did not have the luxury of being able to bring new parts to every race and had started with the ramped solution, would have a brief dalliance with the crossover solution before realizing the amount of development that would be needed to make It work. As such, it switched to a McLaren-esque Coanda solution during the season instead..

Ferrari F2012 different 'Acer duct' exhaust configurations used

Ferrari F2012 different 'Acer duct' exhaust configurations used

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

Ferrari remained an outlier throughout, preferring to try and modify its 'Acer' duct solution on an ad-hoc basis while it worked out the best way to maximize the Coanda solution that it finally introduced.

The FIA let the use of these Coanda style exhausts slide for 2013 knowing the financial burden that teams had gone through to develop them. It was acutely aware that with the new hybrid rules coming into play for 2014, the ability to blow the diffuser with the exhaust would no longer be viable.

So, whilst it was never specifically banned by a target new rule, the regulations were altered to account for it. With the exhaust having to exit along the car's centerline going forward the days of blown floors were over.

Read Also:

shares
comments
F1 staff face new reality as factories reopen

Previous article

F1 staff face new reality as factories reopen

Next article

Horner: No better time for reverse-grid experiment

Horner: No better time for reverse-grid experiment
Load comments
The unexpected benefit of F1's sprint race repeat Prime

The unexpected benefit of F1's sprint race repeat

OPINION: Formula 1's sprint race trial at Silverstone drew mixed feedback on Saturday, but there remained the true test of how it would impact Sunday's Grand Prix. While fans were busy marvelling at Fernando Alonso's progress, a key lesson was being learned that would directly contribute to the dramatic lap-one clash at Copse the following day

Formula 1
Jul 22, 2021
The off-track considerations that led to Hamilton/Verstappen F1 shunt Prime

The off-track considerations that led to Hamilton/Verstappen F1 shunt

OPINION: Formula 1’s 2021 title fight turned ugly last weekend when Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton collided at the start of the British Grand Prix. Verstappen thankfully walked away unharmed, but this had been a clash long-since coming.

Formula 1
Jul 21, 2021
British Grand Prix Driver Ratings Prime

British Grand Prix Driver Ratings

The 2021 British Grand Prix will live long in the memory for the dramatic clash between Formula 1's two title protagonists, which opened the door for other drivers to capitalise. One did so in spectacular fashion, while others fluffed their lines

Formula 1
Jul 19, 2021
How Leclerc almost defied Hamilton after Silverstone clash Prime

How Leclerc almost defied Hamilton after Silverstone clash

A poor start for Valtteri Bottas and the lap one clash between Formula 1's 2021 title protagonists gave Charles Leclerc a surprise lead in the British Grand Prix that he almost held to the end. Here's how the Ferrari driver came close to a famous victory, ultimately denied by a recovering Lewis Hamilton three laps from home

Formula 1
Jul 19, 2021
The signs that suggest Mercedes can win at Silverstone Prime

The signs that suggest Mercedes can win at Silverstone

Red Bull and Max Verstappen scored an early blow against Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes at Silverstone, with sprint qualifying race victory. But that doesn’t mean Sunday’s grand prix is a foregone conclusion. Although Verstappen starts as the favourite, here’s why Mercedes still holds hope of winning

Formula 1
Jul 18, 2021
Uncovering Silverstone's engineering secrets for F1 success Prime

Uncovering Silverstone's engineering secrets for F1 success

Formula 1 returns to Silverstone this weekend, but despite its familiarity to all the teams it is no picnic. Here are five of the key points for engineers to consider prior to the British Grand Prix.

Formula 1
Jul 16, 2021
The 'special relationship' Ferrari will hope to exploit at Silverstone Prime

The 'special relationship' Ferrari will hope to exploit at Silverstone

Ferrari might have snubbed the very first world championship race on British soil but the Scuderia and the UK went on to enjoy some deep connections. As BEN EDWARDS explains, theirs is a shared history that is waiting for its next chapter to be written...

Formula 1
Jul 15, 2021
The political manoeuvring behind F1's return to British GP normality Prime

The political manoeuvring behind F1's return to British GP normality

OPINION: Formula 1 heads back to Silverstone this weekend for the 2021 British Grand Prix, where a full-capacity crowd will return after a painful absence in the initial stages of the COVID-19 pandemic last year. Here’s how the pieces that permitted a part of returning ‘normal’ life were arranged.

Formula 1
Jul 14, 2021