Formula 1 Monaco GP

The communication breakdown that led to Haas's Monaco disqualification

Haas has explained how a communications breakdown triggered its exclusion from qualifying for Formula 1's Monaco Grand Prix for an illegal rear wing.

Jonathan Noble

Published: May 26, 2024, 10:33 AM

Copy link

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Haas VF-24 technical detail

Nico Hulkenberg and Kevin Magnussen were disqualified on Saturday after post-session examinations of their cars showed their DRS wings opened more than the 85mm that is allowed in the rules.

Talking about how Haas had found itself in such a situation, team principal Ayao Komatsu said it mainly revolved around a lack of communication between the departments of his team about the implications of a new rear wing design.

A concept shift meant the rear wing elements sloped up near the endplate, something that needed to be taken into account when setting the maximum allowance for DRS opening.

However, the design department had not explicitly warned the track team about this matter, and testing by the squad in Monaco had not been thorough enough to check the gaps across the entire span.

"If the designers had made it absolutely clear that the design intention was slightly different from the wings you have been using before, so you have to check it in this way, that would have helped," said Komatsu.

"But at the same time, even with other information, the trackside checks should have checked the whole legality surface.

"There was no performance gained, absolutely zero, but that's not the point. The car has to be legal. So, we just have to accept this as a failure of the team, and then learn from it, and make sure we don't make the same mistake again."

Flap DRS open

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

Komatsu believes that the DRS exclusion was something that showed the team needed to improve its processes to prevent a repeat in the future.

"For the designer who designed it, in his mind it's clear: this wing is legal, but it's got a different profile. So he needed to think, should I communicate that to make sure that other people who didn't design the thing understand it?

"For the trackside people, if they had had that highlighted it would have helped. But even without that, with a brand-new rear wing, just don't assume anything. You just have to check every single legal surface: that's what we should be doing.

"So again, a bit of complacency, a bit of assumption, without actually thinking 'Okay, this is the new rear wing, it could be different.' We just need to improve working as a team."

With the wing issue being more about how the team set the maximum DRS opening, it has not needed a change of specification for the race, so the team avoids a pitlane start.

Asked what the team would be running in the race, Komatsu said: "It's the same wing, but we can adjust it. With the DRS open gap, there is a mechanism to adjust it for where you are going to get to the maximum.

"We have a parc ferme request to adjust it. So that is legal, and it's been approved. So, we adjust it on both cars and we start from P19 to P20."

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Viber

Previous article McLaren insists it can win F1 Monaco GP without crucial pole

Next article F1 live: The Monaco GP as it happened

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

Latest news

Toyota clinches 2026 NASCAR Cup manufacturer championship early after dominant season

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup

Phoenix II

2 h

Toyota clinches 2026 NASCAR Cup manufacturer championship early after dominant season

Tyler Reddick really needed NASCAR Phoenix win for several reasons

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup

Phoenix II

2 h

Tyler Reddick really needed NASCAR Phoenix win for several reasons

Bubba Wallace laments mistake after heartbreaking Phoenix loss

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup

Phoenix II

3 h

Bubba Wallace laments mistake after heartbreaking Phoenix loss

NASCAR is getting the championship finish it has pursued since 1992

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup

Phoenix II

3 h

NASCAR is getting the championship finish it has pursued since 1992

Feature

Discover prime content

How levelling the playing field isn’t antithetical to the principles of F1

Formula 1

By Pat Symonds

How levelling the playing field isn’t antithetical to the principles of F1

Lights, Camara, action: How Haas picked F1's latest rookie for 2027

Formula 1

Singapore GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

Lights, Camara, action: How Haas picked F1's latest rookie for 2027

Employing team orders can simply be a matter of common sense

Formula 1

By Kevin Turner

Employing team orders can simply be a matter of common sense

Why Christian Horner sees history repeating itself for Adrian Newey at Aston Martin

Formula 1

Singapore GP

By Ronald Vording

Why Christian Horner sees history repeating itself for Adrian Newey at Aston Martin

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Become a subscriber.
Disable your adblocker.

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts